Israel exists somewhere between hope and reality. Before 1948, Israel was an ideal place, a word that exemplified hope for a different and distinct reality from the thousands of years of Jewish exile and dispersion. In reality, Israel is a modern state that lives in an unbearable reality, swinging between a desire for peace, frustration, and trauma, choosing to live without peace. Telling the “true” story of Israel is impossible, yet many Israelis feel the need to have their own stories heard so that others understand their reality. Using the Hasidic storytelling tradition, one that seeks to preserve the tension rather than resolve it and one that concentrates on story rather than “historical truth”, the process becomes a way for both storyteller and listener to gain an understanding of and connection to one another.